Sonic the Hedgehog(PS3) or Sonic Wildfire(Wii)?

[Wildfire the Dragon]

I've been to a few places, and some seems to argue about which Sonic is better, Sonic the Hedgehog or Sonic Wildfire. I don't have a clue, so what do you think?


Here's Sonic the Hedgehog...


...And Sonic Wildfire.


And remember, everyone has their opinion, so no fighting, unlike the others...
---
Hmm...I like the look on StH, however Eggman's new look is messed up. Also, SW keeps some of the old school Sonic...so I can't choose. Heck, if I have enough, I'll get the PS3 and Wii just for those! ^^

[Not-Garr]

I like the PS3 version just because I don't like my Sega and my Nintendo mixed. <.=.>

[Lord of the Dance]

I'm probably not going to get a PS3, but it looks delicious.

...My parents don't even want to get a Wii. But if they don't get it, I'm going to pool my money until I get one.
They want to get a Gamecube. I have no idea why.

But anyways, Sonic Wildfire seems unique enough. I just wonder where all the other characters went =P

And what about the Chao?
And why did Sonic have a flame on his chest?

[Teo]

Well well well...

I'm going to wait to vote on this one. Only because one's a trailer meant to look really good and one's a recording of a guy playing.

I'll wait till the Sonic Wildfire trailer comes out to vote...

[Chilaquiles]

Funny vote turnout so far, here.

I'm done with Sonic games, so I voted neither.

[Yoshi]

Hmm. The Ps3 one seemed more like what you'd see as a movie preview, the Wii one like just the gameplay demo.

Sonic. Never really been a big fan. Although I'm confused at the Ps3 one, did they just add another white hedgehog or is that Sonic in another "Super" form?

[Wildfire the Dragon]

admin said:

Hmm. The Ps3 one seemed more like what you'd see as a movie preview, the Wii one like just the gameplay demo.

Sonic. Never really been a big fan. Although I'm confused at the Ps3 one, did they just add another white hedgehog or is that Sonic in another "Super" form?

His name is Silver. He's from the future to kill the "Ibis Trigger," which is Sonic(Possibly). He used psychic abilties to levitate items, somewhat similar to the Half Life 2 Gravity Gun. He's not as fast as Sonic or Shadow, so his style is exploration, a little like Rogue and Knuckles, but far different.

That's all I know, we'll have to wait until the PS3 comes out I guess(This November).

[Max "Snow" Andershi]

yosheechamp said:

...My parents don't even want to get a Wii. But if they don't get it, I'm going to pool my money until I get one.
They want to get a Gamecube. I have no idea why.

Tell them that the Wii will also play Gamecube discs and use Gamecube controllers and memory cards for said discs, which means that it's a better value overall, since you'll be able to play both Gamecube and Wii games on it =D Not to mention the potential of the Wii Virtual Console..

But anyway, being a Sonic fan myself, ((As well as a Mario fan, obviously; why would I be here if I didn't like the games? XD)) I think that both of them look interesting, however I think Wildfire ((Which I think has a new working title of "Sonic and the Secret of the Scrolls" as of this week)) shows a bit more potential to be fun.. At any rate, it looks like a more successful endeavor to bring back some of the classic things from the series, while adding a new twist on gameplay since you tilt the Wii controller to move Sonic..

The PS3/360 Sonic still has a bit to prove.. Sonic Team have been in a funk lately as they've admittedly been designing games like Sonic Heroes and Shadow for younger audiences, and they said they were trying to make the new one more for an older age group, I believe.. But having yet another hedgehog seems kind of silly, and his game doesn't even really offer any speed, but then again, his game's bound to be more fun than Big's fishing stages; eugh =P

Anyway, I think I need to wait and see how they both play, but for the moment, Wildfire's caught my eye more readily

[Masakuni]

As much as I want both the games, I don't think I'll ever get an Xbox 360 or PS3, so that StH game is out of the question...guess I'll just get the Sonic Wildfire (I think it's a different name now btw) one

[Yoshiken]

Eh, Im not much of a Sonic guy ^^, so I wouldn't really want any of them XD.

Ill get a PS3 after my mission, or at least that is what my disfigured reality is telling me ^^.